We're giving you the chance to win back the value of your meal - every time you dine this month!

SquareMeal Review of The Abbey Inn Byland

Gold Award

It’s hard to imagine Michelin-starred chef Tommy Banks washing pots here as a child, who 25 odd years later now occupies the role of chef director at The Abbey Inn. It’s something of a full-circle moment. Together with his team, he’s helped transform the 19th-century inn into a destination restaurant and pub with rooms, and the results are dazzling.

For one, it's overlooked by the statuesque ruins of Byland Abbey, which makes for spectacular viewing if you’re just popping by for a pint in its lush garden. Inside follows a similar historic theme. As we’re guided through a network of intimate rooms and cosy corners, we take stock of its original low beamed ceilings, rustic furniture and stone floors. Having said that, our table is situated in one of its more spacious rooms, the sun streaming through a huge skylight directly above us.

The menu champions a hyper-seasonal, sustainable approach to food and drink, with most of its produce grown and reared on Oldstead Farm up the road. Make no mistake, this is a proper country pub, and you won’t go far wrong with its signature beef burger. Even the precursory bread is a thing to behold, a beyond-fresh seeded loaf served with two types of butter, one flecked with pounded cheese and the other a verdant herby creation. From the specials list, a starter of asparagus with a poached egg - so often barely more than the sum of its parts - is elevated to new heights with salty ox tongue and an avalanche of Parmesan.

You’ll find more gastropubby options on the menu too, like charcoal-cooked halibut in a heavenly yoghurt whey and chamomile sauce, with fresh peas and samphire. The finale arrives in the form of three pastel-hued soft serve ice cream flavours, from lemon verbena to strawberry Eton mess. It’s the cherry on top of a faultless meal.

Finally, herbaceous cocktails, a considered wine list and local ales and spirits make for exciting reading when it comes to the drinks menu. All in all, dining at The Abbey Inn is a joyful experience from start to finish.

Read more +

Good to know

Average Price
££££ - £50 - £79
Cuisine
British, Vegetarian friendly
Ambience
Cosy, Traditional
Awards
SquareMeal UK Top 100
Food Occasions
Dinner, Lunch, Sunday roast
Alfresco And Views
Terrace
Perfect for
Celebrations, Child friendly

About

The Abbey Inn is steeped in history - it was originally built by monks in 1845 as a farmhouse, using ‘borrowed’ stones from nearby Byland Abbey, but by 1853 it had been converted into a public house. The Abbey Inn Byland is a historic Grade-II listed pub and restaurant run by Tommy Banks - the head chef and owner of Michelin-starred Roots York and The Black Swan at Oldstead. As is the case at other Banks restaurants, produce all comes from the nearby Banks farm and garden, including their own meat which is reared just a mile away from the pub.

The Abbey Inn is a relaxed country pub and restaurant, with a handful of rooms attached for overnight stays. As well as a newly-renovated dining room, The Abbey Inn also features a cosy bar area, with roaring open fires to warm you on colder days.

The kitchen team is led by head chef Callum Leslie, who is also executive chef at The Black Swan. The menu is full of reimagined classics with interesting touches - a signature of Banks’ other restaurants. Dishes on the menu at the time of writing include smoked baby beetroot, ewe’s curd and ‘rhuboshi’, salt aged bavette tartare with fermented peppers and smoked bone marrow, and glazed Herdwick lamb rib with yoghurt flatbread and fermented carrots to name but a few. Hearty mains include The Byland burger - a Dexter chuck brisket and short rib patty, topped with bacon and chicory jam and served alongside pork fat fries.

The dessert menu features carrot and chicory tiramisu as well as an array of soft serve sundaes. Meanwhile the bar is stocked with an array of local beers and Banks Brothers canned wines.

Read more +

FAQs

Who owns the pub?

The pub is owned by Tommy Banks, the Michelin-starred chef of Roots York and The Black Swan at Oldstead

Does it cater for vegetarians and vegans?

There is a vegetarian menu but the kitchen only has a limited number of vegan dishes.

What is the cancellation policy?

The team kindly require guests to provide a minimum of 24 hours notice if not able to attend

Details

Get directions to The Abbey Inn Byland Get directions to The Abbey Inn Byland
Location
Byland, York, North Yorkshire, YO61 4BD

Website

Opening Times

Dinner
Mon Closed
Tue Closed
Wed Closed
Thu 17:00-23:00
Fri Closed
Sat Closed
Sun Closed
All day
Mon 12:00-23:00
Tue Closed
Wed Closed
Thu Closed
Fri 12:00-23:00
Sat 12:00-23:00
Sun 12:00-21:00

Reviews

Share your thoughts with other diners

Write a review


1 Review 
Food/Drink
Service
Atmosphere
Value

Anon

16 May 2025  
Food & Drink 2
Service 3.5
Atmosphere 3.5
Value 1
Overpriced and very mediocre food. Avoid!

First impressions were amazing: the pub sits opposite the ruins of Byland Abbey, a huge Cistercian monastery. The pub is very relaxing and well appointed, though a little noisy. The staff are attentive and efficient and food was served and cleared away quickly. But now we come to the elephant in the room: the food. The pub is owned by Tommy Banks, who has a Michelin starred restaurant a couple of miles away in Oldstead, and this pub is listed in the Michelin guide. It would not be in mine. I did not like the look of any of the starters, all of which contained elements I'd rather not eat, That's my problem, not theirs. So I skipped them. I decided to go with the main course of 8oz Salt-Aged Dexter Beef Ribeye with a peppercorn sauce, triple cooked chips and Hispi cabbage at 43.50. The cabbage, served with a really clever topping was fabulous. The peppercorn sauce was perfectly decent. The chips were tasty but nothing like triple cooked chips: Heston Blumenthal (who invented them) describes them as "chips with a glass-like crust and a soft, fluffy centre" . I found 2 that I could stick a fork into. The rest were just solidly crispy. And then we come to the steak. It was cooked as I asked, medium rare. But whereas it may have been 8oz when it started life, I doubt if it was 5oz when it reached my plate. And if I have been fed it whilst blindfolded, I would have struggled to identify it as steak, so bland was it. There was no evidence of seasoning. My reference for steak is Forest in York, which does an 8oz rump with chips, onion rings, mushrooms, vine tomatoes and a brandy and peppercorn sauce for 25.95. I suggest Mr Banks visits there and has a long, hard look at his offering, because it does not come remotely close. If I had not been in a group I might (for the first time ever in my life) have complained. Still hungry after my considerably less than enthralling main, I chose Raspberry Frangipane Tart with Raspberry Sorbet for 13.00. The tart was nice, but the portion size was on the small size, What saved it was the beautiful sorbet, which was intensly delicious. The other slight saviour of the meal was the heavenly Helmsley IPA beer on the bar. My share of the bill (including 2 pints and a 12.5% service charge, came to just under £80. Was it good value? Well last week, I ate a 2 course meal at the Goodmanham Arms in East Yorkshire. I had 2 courses which both blew the Abbey Inn's efforts away in both quality and quantity. The cost, with 2 pints of beer, came to £30. So I'm afraid the Abbey Inn is VERY poor value.

Book a table

Visit their website

Sorry, you cannot spend SquareMeal vouchers here yet.

Other restaurants we like near The Abbey Inn Byland

The Abbey Inn Byland
Close