Offer Finder

  • Search Available Offers

Book with us & collect points to spend on fantastic rewards. It is that simple.
Learn more »?

Register here for your Square Meal Guides

 
 
(menu)

David's Reviews

David T.Over 60, Male, United Kingdom

Member since October 2006

Silver reviewer since March 2009.

Reviews written: 12 (10 voted helpful)

Restaurants rated: 1 (this year)

Hasn't posted in the forum yet

Favourited by: 5 members

James Duckett at the Old Custom House (The Strand, Barnstaple, Devon EX31 1EU)

Excellent restaurant, now sadly closed, as the chef is moving to a hotel in Umberleigh. For those like me based in Ilfracombe, you might try Trimstone Manor, just outside, or Gaspacho on Wilder Road.

30 July 2011

Overall:7
Food and Drink:7
Service:6
Atmosphere:6
Value for Money:8
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

The Restaurant at Aviator Hotel (Farnborough Road, Farnborough, Hampshire, GU14 6XA)

The number of decent restaurants this close to Aldershot can be counted on the fingers of one foot, so I was quite keen to try this, on a Sunday, with my wife and daughter.

The building outside is aggressively modern and looked rather deserted. On venturing inside, through automatic doors, again it looked deserted until a porter spotted us and showed us to the restaurant, to a friendly greeting from the lady at the desk. To avoid undue repetition, I will say here that all the staff we dealt with were, without exception, friendly, helpful and just nice. The decor is all brown and cream and the tables are reasonably well spaced. They are also a decent size.

The menus and wine list both come on a single sided sheet about A3 size, with the food menu written rather large, in order that the not excessive choice should take up the whole space. The wine list was typed in a more normal font and had a reasonable selection, better than I have seen in many hotel restaurants, with several listed by the glass (in two sizes). I started with a large (250ml) glass of NZ sauvignon blanc at £8.35. A pretty average specimen. I then went on to an Aussie Pinot Noir (£32.96 the bottle), a likewise average specimen.

The menu bore no resemblance to that described in the Square Meal review or, indeed, to that shown on the hotel website. Square Meal describes the cooking as modern European and the website shows a menu touching pretty much all the bases you would expect from this description. The menu we were presented with could have come from any run of the mill hotel. The most obvious choice was steak, fillet, rib eye or sirloin being on offer and featured prominently. There were also 4 so-called “Classic” dishes, of which I recall slow-cooked lamb shoulder (which my wife and daughter had) and chicken curry. There was no discernable theme to the menu, other than a desire, understandable in a hotel, to include something to please everyone. I started with the asparagus, as did my wife, and went on… More

May 2009

Overall:5
Food and Drink:5
Service:8
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:8
1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Chapters all Day Dining (43-45 Montpelier Vale, London, SE3 0TJ)

Editor's pick

This recently reopened after refurbishment and under the new name “Chapters All Day Dining”. This was, in fact, my third visit, after a dinner and breakfast during the first week, when food prices were reduced and customers were expected to put up with the occasional glitch, which, indeed, happened. I should mention that we are regulars at the parent, Chapter 1, and were regulars at the predecessor of Chapters, and so are fairly well known to the staff, many of whom have a history at one or other of those restaurants.

On this occasion, two of my party, wife and daughter, were on crutches, and the management, knowing this, had kindly reserved us a table close to the door to minimise walking.

For those familiar with the old Chapter 2, the new restaurant is a complete change in very many ways. For a start, the former coffee house has been subsumed into the main restaurant, giving the upstairs a much more open and less cluttered feel. The menu, too, is totally different, much more brasserie than the former modern European. To me, this is good, as it means that Chapter 1 and Chapters now offer a choice of cuisine types, instead of Chapter 2 being, as it was, a somewhat pale imitation of its parent. The décor, black, off-white, glass and brick, is not especially to my taste, but it certainly makes a point. The main criticism I have of the new arrangement is that the prevalence of hard surfaces means that, when full, as it was, the room gets rather uncomfortably noisy. My daughter says that the room now feels comfortable, and I think this is right. The chairs are comfortable for lengthy sitting. In one corner there is a bar with seating. There is also some seating outside, which was well used during our visits.

On our arrival, at about 8.30pm on a Saturday evening, the upstairs was pretty full, as it stayed during the evening, with people arriving well after we did. Although I did not see downstairs, one of the staff told me that it, too, was busy. My son-in-law and I drank a… More

May 2009

Overall:6
Food and Drink:8
Service:4
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:9
3 of 3 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Michael Wignall at the Latymer at Pennyhill Park Hotel (Pennyhill Park Hotel, London Road, Bagshot, Surrey, GU19 5EU)

My wife and I, with a daughter and her boyfriend, stayed for a night, mainly with a view to trying the restaurant, 1 Michelin star, formerly run by one of our favourite chefs, Andrew Turner, now at Landau, but now the province of Michael Wignall. The hotel has two restaurants, the Latymer, where we ate, and the brasserie, so it is perhaps not too great a surprise that the Latymer, on our arrival at 7.30pm, had only one other table occupied, by a couple. It is, perhaps, more surprising that only two other tables (one 4 and one couple) were occupied throughout our meal. Although this was mid-week, I would not have expected quite such a lack of customers.
All of the tables had been set, all but one with white fabric cloths. Our table, a round one in the middle of the room, had a inlaid wooden top which it would have been a pity to cover. We were seated in comfortable chairs.
Although the website suggests that over 200 wines are available by the glass, this was not obvious from the wine list, which listed a reasonable number, certainly less than a dozen of each colour, but nowhere near 200. Perhaps the website is out of date. The list had a decent selection of bottles and did not seem grossly overpriced.
Service was mostly correct, if a little frosty at times, mainly by a young lady who plainly did not speak English very well. When she had delivered each course, she then told each diner what was on his or her plate, presumably in case we had forgotten. This might have been useful to the many amnesiac diners the restaurant doubtless gets, had she identified the ingredients correctly. However, several times what she said did not precisely match what was on the plate – she got the main ingredient correct, but the others were all over the place.
Sadly, none of us found the food to be as enjoyable as we had expected. Every single dish was, to my mind too fussy, with too many ingredients, too many tastes and not enough of any one to give much more than a mouthful of anything. For… More

February 2009

Overall:4
Food and Drink:5
Service:4
Atmosphere:4
Value for Money:3
1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Le Cassoulet (18 Selsden Road, London, London, CR2 6PA)

Le Cassoulet, Croydon.
Booked for 7.30pm on Sunday evening, but arrived at 8.15pm (after phoning to warn of our late arrival) to a friendly welcome. Something, perhaps the maroon walls, made me think for a moment that I had entered an Indian restaurant. The restaurant has a bar, with some seats, near the entrance and extends quite some way back, but the large room was mainly empty, with perhaps 4 tables occupied. I later asked a waiter if the lack of customers was down to the snow which had begun falling that evening, but he replied that Sundays were always slow.
While my wife was parking the car, I ordered a caffe latte and a jug of tap water for her and a bottle of sparkling water for me. These came quickly. I subsequently ordered a bottle of Vacqueyras (£29) which took a little longer to arrive and was the 2005 vintage, rather than the 2004 vintage listed. The waiter, not unusually, did not mention the difference in vintage and I did not feel like making an issue of it. It could have done with longer in bottle, but was a decent example of the wine.
I chose to start with the rabbit salad and go on to the cassoulet, whilst my wife chose the shallot & gruyere tart followed by assiette of hare. The hare comes with truffle mash, which she asked to have served in a side dish, which it was.
The tart was a fairly standard quiche, with a pretty mild flavour of cheese. My rabbit salad was more interesting. Several portions of loin, some liver on a cocktail stick, mushrooms, a sticky brown savoury sauce and some croutons, all covering a small pile of greenery. There was quite a variety of flavours, ranging from the very mild loin to the hefty kick of the liver. Unlike some dishes I have had, the flavours all went well together.
My wife’s assiette of hare was a small pie and a large quantity of what appeared to be fairly rare hare – looking purple and bloody. I did not fancy trying it, but my wife enjoyed it. I was first presented with an empty soup dish, then a casserole, filled to… More

February 2009

Overall:6
Food and Drink:6
Service:6
Atmosphere:4
Value for Money:7
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Restaurant Critic


Seaview Hotel (High Street, Seaview, Isle of Wight, Isle of Wight, PO34 5EX)

Editor's pick

My wife & I recently (mid-week, January 2009) spent three nights here. Off season, obviously. Even so, the restaurant managed to attract around 20+ guests each evening, many plainly locals.

Out of season, the menu choices are rather restricted to around 4 in each course. However, the chef has recently introduced a new option – a 5-course tasting menu, which he says will be geared to your preferences. My wife & I decided to have this on each night of our stay, and the chefs managed to come up with 15 different dishes, without too much fish (I’m not too fond) and with no fois gras (my wife doesn't like it). After the first evening, we were asked if there was anything we would particularly like for the third evening and we asked for duck, which was not on the menu – the rest of the dishes were, so far as I could tell, ringing the changes on ingredients that were available for regular menu dishes. The duck came in a savoury sauce, with an almost burnt taste, that went strangely well. Other highlights for me were belly of pork in a black pudding sauce, beef and fried Isle of Wight cheese.

We were here last year and felt that the food then, although quite good, did not show much imagination. That has certainly changed.

Service is from smart mostly young people, who appear to have been well trained. The wine list is surprisingly wide ranging for what is, after all, a seaside hotel. Perhaps it is not so surprising – the restaurant manager used to be the sommelier at Chapter 1 in Kent.

If you plan to stay, I can recommend the rooms in the new block, which are very modern and benefit from free wired broadband (I am not sure they have enough bandwidth since it seems to slow to an unusable crawl on occasion) and an interesting lift. The only disadvantage of these is that you have to walk through the small, unattractive car park to get to the main part of the hotel.

Money where my mouth is – my wife & I have booked to return for another three nights in February.

January 2009

Overall:8
Food and Drink:8
Service:9
Atmosphere:6
Value for Money:7
1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Trinity (4 The Polygon, London, London, SW4 0JG)

We arrived about 10 minutes late, having booked for 7.30pm, to a warm welcome from one of the long-serving staff and an unusually empty restaurant. We have been coming here since it first opened and so the staff know what we like to start the meal, with the result that a latte, cranberry juice, tap water and salad appeared for my wife, and I got a bottle of sparkling water, all within minutes of sitting down and without asking. I asked for a glass of Alpha Zeta chardonnay, a pleasant Italian version, at £5.20 a glass. Note that the website shows it at £4.50 a glass which suggests that a little up-dating would not go amiss.

The room is modern, mostly white, with some abstract art on the walls. There is a bar in one corner, at which one can sit before the meal. There is also a partly secluded alcove with a large table seating 8 comfortably and possibly a few more at a squeeze – this has a window into the kitchen, which can be interesting. In summer, the large windows at one end of the room are often opened, effectively bringing the room into the open air. However, on the October Tuesday of our visit, the weather was not conducive to this. Given that my wife recently had a knee operation and my back was playing up, we were both rather happy that the loos are on the same floor, so very disabled friendly. The tables are fairly close, but not unusually so for a London restaurant and certainly not as close as in Racine or the Neal St Restaurant.

The format of the menu has changed slightly, and we were told that they now make slight changes often, even daily, which has not always been the case, in order to accommodate the varying availability of game. On this evening, there were two choices of game, red legged partridge and hare. I love partridge, but rarely see hare on a menu, and so I chose that, as did my wife. Nothing much of the starters appealed, and so my wife, bravely, chose to start with the beef cottage pie from the main courses, while I asked if I could have a small… More

October 2008

Overall:8
Food and Drink:8
Service:8
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:8
2 of 2 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Chapter One (Locksbottom, Farnborough Common, Kent BR6 8NF)

Before you read this review, you should know that my family and I have been coming here for ages, through at least 4 managers, and are very well known, and so I am the very antithesis of the anonymous reviewer.

The restaurant is located on the A21, near a busy crossroads and on the outskirts of the village of Locksbottom. When we, my wife and I, arrived, on a Monday evening, the car park was pretty full, but the restaurant was only half full – the explanation was a function going on in the private room upstairs. Incidentally, I have used the private room in the past and it’s a good place for a private dinner party of 15-30 people.

Even half full, the room was buzzing and I would guess there were some 40-50 people.

We were quickly shown to our usual table and brought the menus, but no wine list. My wife was then brought her caffe latte and salad ( a standing order in all our regular restaurants) but still no wine list. My guess is that it was some 10-15 minutes before one was brought. I had the impression throughout our meal that there were simply not enough waiting staff, and this was subsequently confirmed by an assistant manager (the manager was off that night) who told us that a couple who were supposed to be on had not turned up.

When I finally managed to order some wine, I started with a glass of chardonnay (I believe it was from the USA, but am not certain – £5.50). I then went on to a NZ Pinot, Alana 2004, well worth it at £43, served in decently large glasses.

Maybe I eat out too much, but when I saw the menu, I was not too sure I fancied anything. The chef here turns out excellent food, but he doesn’t ring the changes all that often, at least with the meat dishes which are pretty much all I eat. However, I settled for jugged hare to start and lamb as the main, with a side of new potatoes (£2.50 – enough for the two of us, except when we are being greedy). My wife also chose the hare and asked if the quail could be served without the accompanying fois gras, of… More

September 2008

Overall:8
Food and Drink:8
Service:5
Atmosphere:6
Value for Money:9
1 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

The Square (6-10 Bruton Street, London, London, W1J 6PU)

My wife and I used to be regulars at The Square in its former location in St James. However, when it moved, it lost a certain humanity, not to mention gaining a few pounds, and we never felt sufficiently at ease to include it among our regulars. The last time we went was probably a year ago – I only recognised one of the staff and none of them recognised us.

However, when we arrived, precisely on time (it was Sunday and the traffic was light), we were greeted in a friendly manner by the receptionist. This was the friendliest of any that we came into contact with, the rest being correct (mainly) but distant. One table containing two young(ish) casually dressed men attracted much more attentive and friendly service to the extent that I suspect those two men were members of staff.

My wife ordered her usual, which came without any fuss. I had a glass of German riesling (£9) and a bottle of sparkling water. The riesling was pleasant but a somewhat ungenerous glass. I followed that with a bottle of Cornas Reynard 1996 at £95 – pleasant, as it should be.

We were each presented with a wooden block bearing canapés, which were nice enough, but not memorable.

Not being a lover of fish, I had very little choice of starter – one vegetarian option, some fried fois gras or a parfait of fois gras and chicken livers. The vegetarian option looked boring, as it often does, and so, although I am attempting to cut down on fois gras, I had the parfait. This came in three parts: a Kilner jar bearing an inch or so of parfait; a medium size plate bearing a salad; and a couple of slices of toasted Poilane bread. The salad had some Jerusalem artichokes, pickled onions and several sweet dollops, which, once I had established what they were, I left. My wife was afraid the onions would wreck the wine, but they were so lightly pickled and so mild that they did not. The parfait was a sloppy deep beige mixture coated on top with salted peanut crisp, which added a contrast in texture but little else… More

September 2008

Overall:7
Food and Drink:9
Service:4
Atmosphere:4
Value for Money:4
7 of 8 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

The Only Running Footman (5 Charles Street, London, London, W1J 5DF)

We arrived a bit late, climbed the stairs besides a heaving pub and, passing between the ladies and gents loos, arrived in a half empty room devoid of staff.

After politely waiting around for a few minutes, we were just about to go to the table obviously set for us (unless they happened to have another party of 5 to go with the few couples scattered around) when a waiter appeared and brusquely enquired how many we were; not whether we had booked, or our names, or our inside leg measurements, but the one item of information that he could have determined for himself had his maths been up to the task.

He then pointed us to the obvious table and brought menus and a wine list. When it became clear that my wife’s requirements extended beyond the usual still, sparkling or tap, he sensibly got out a notepad and quickly and efficiently dealt with the orders.

Just to keep me going, I had a glass of Albarino (£7), very pleasant, and a generous size glass. Subsequently, I ordered a bottle of Mansion House sauvignon blanc (£27) and Dillons Pinot Noir (£32), both from NZ and both good examples of their type.

I did not follow what everyone else had. However, their consensus was that it was good but not exceptional.

I started with a warm salad of pigeon, pigeon tasty and moist plus a few odd leaves (not too many) and other stuff. I then went on to wild duck, with a side order of chips. The chips were large, but crisp on the outside and fluffy within. Although I prefer my chips more chip-size than quarter potato size, these were good. I did, however, have a problem with the duck. This came as a breast, cooked pink and a confit pie. The breast was cooked as it should be and tasted ducky. It did not, however, taste especially wild. The pie had a thin top and a thick and claggy base. I think the base was somewhat thicker than the filling. After a couple of exceedingly unpleasant mouthfuls, I took off the top, scraped off and ate the meagre filling and left the pastry, which rather destroys… More

September 2008

Overall:5
Food and Drink:6
Service:4
Atmosphere:5
Value for Money:5
4 of 4 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Belair Park Brasserie (Gallery Road, London, SE21 7AB)

Having originally booked for 4 people, we changed this to 6 a few hours before we were due to arrive. My wife said the telephone staff were fine.

We arrived a few minutes after 8pm on Thursday, to find the receptionist on the phone. My impression was that she was talking to a friend. My daughter said that the receptionist had mentioned the number of covers (35), so it is possible that she was reporting to her boss. Either way, we were kept waiting for several minutes while she finished her leisurely call.

We were then shown to our table.

My wife and I have been coming here infrequently ever since it opened as Belair House some years ago. The basic design concept of minimalist modern white in a fabulous Georgian house has remained the same, although the general standard, and probably expense, of the décor has gradually improved. Originally, as Belair House, it was ridiculously expensive for out of town and fairly average food, with the result that our visits were infrequent. My oldest daughter suggested that the place would benefit from a little dusting on the ledge behind the white banquette she was sitting at. Also, it was strange, on a warm June evening, to find a radiator slightly warm, as though it had only recently been turned off.

While the waitress handed out the menus, I was explaining to my family that the last time we came, and the reason we had not been for a long time, the menu was a weird and unpleasant attempt at a fusion of French and Japanese, but that, based on the Square Meal review, I believed they had given up this abomination. On opening my menu, I found a weird and unexciting attempt at a fusion of French and Japanese! The trouble was that I, and most of the family, found it difficult, on the basis of the menu, to find anything that we particularly wanted to eat. In the end, for the mains, 3 of us, myself included, settled for the least oriental, beef fillet with pepper sauce and dauphinoise potatoes (£5 supplement). Two others had fish and one… More

September 2008

Overall:5
Food and Drink:5
Service:4
Atmosphere:7
Value for Money:6
5 of 5 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

The Wolseley (160 Piccadilly, London, London, W1J 9EB)

I arrived a couple of minutes before the booked time, 7pm, to a friendly welcome from the doorman and a confusion of people just inside the door. However, I was soon shown to our table, to find that I was the first to arrive. However, my host and the other guest arrived within a few minutes. I had ordered a bottle of sparkling water on my arrival, and this turned up shortly after the rest had seated and was distributed among us.

The room is enormous, rather grand, and, I believe, has further seating upstairs at one end. We were seated on a small table, just big enough for 3, in close proximity to our neighbours on my left. The room was fairly noisy and very, very crowded. The tables, as is too common in London, were crammed together, to make the most of very expensive floor space.

Throughout the meal, the service was correct and professional, but not friendly. However, it is to his credit that the waiter who took orders, on a couple of occasions, came up to the table primed to do so and, seeing us deep in conversation, silently went away.

Two of us each started with a Kir Royale, and the other had a lager. The Kir Royale was well made without the usual excess of cassis. We then went on to bottle of Haut Medoc, which I believe is the 2003 Château Liversan, on the list at £29.50, and very pleasant. We had at least one further bottle of this.

The menu is enormous, covering a wide range of food types from soup and sandwich to a full scale meal. I started with roast quail and lentils. This seemed to be a whole bird cut into 4 pieces in a sea of lentils. The quail was somewhat lacking in taste, but the broth in which the lentils were swimming made up for it. However, in the end, a rather unsatisfying dish.

My main was the Thursday dish of the day, duck parmentier. This was a small round of shredded duck flesh, very thoroughly cooked, and surmounted by mashed potato – a duck version of shepherd’s pie. There was also a meaty gravy, which was really needed, as the duck and… More

September 2008

Overall:5
Food and Drink:5
Service:5
Atmosphere:3
Value for Money:3
5 of 6 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal
Advertisement