Offer Finder

  • Search Available Offers

Register here for your Square Meal Guides

 
 
(menu)

David's Reviews

David K.Over 60, Male, London

Member since August 2005

Gold reviewer since February 2012.

Reviews written: 20 (7 voted helpful)

Restaurants rated: 4 (this year)

Hasn't posted in the forum yet

Favourited by: 2 members

IOD Restaurant (116 Pall Mall, London, SW1Y 5ED)

This was a lovely example of how to overcome and put right a problem. I had booked online some time ago, on the IOD website. When we arrived at the restaurant they had no record of our booking and the restaurant was very busy. I have noted here that diners tend to eat earlier and by 7:30/8:00 it was almost empty. The Maitre'd quickly had a table prepared for us. It was rather large for 3 diners but very comfortable in a corner. A complimentary bottle of Champagne then arrived by way of apology. Totally unexpected but very much appreciated.

We had very good service during the meal. The wine list is very good and we enjoyed a bottle of 2005 Gevrey Chambertin that was quite reasonably priced. There is currently a menu price of £28 for 2 courses and £31 for 3 courses. A very reasonable price when you consider the location and the splendour of the venue.

My warm asparagas salad with mushrooms and poached egg was absolutely delicious. Fellow diners had prawns with noodles and duck and mango salad. Very positive feedback from them.

For mains I chose the fillet of beef, for which there is an extra charge of £4.50. It was superb. Cooked exactly how I like it. Very flavoursome and just melted in the mouth. One of my fellow diners made the same choice and we both agreed that it was one of the best we had ever eaten. My third diner had the beetroot tart with melting goats cheese and I gather that, too, was very enjoyable. The accompanying selection of vegetables were well cooked and well presented.

I choose not to have desert. My fellow diners had rhubard parfait with ginger jelly and lemon posset. I am told it was excellent and it certainly was beautifully presented.

We had a small error on the bill but that was very quickly corrected. It was such a good meal that I have already booked the next meal there in a couple of weeks. Whether you are a member of the IOD or not this restaurant comes highly recommended.

10 June 2011

Overall:9
Food and Drink:9
Service:9
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

San Lorenzo Fuoriporta (38 Wimbledon Hill Road, London, SW19 7PA)

Let me begin by saying that the food was mostly excellent. The asparagus and shaved parmesan worked wonderfully. One of the diners had the tricolour salad whih she thoughly enjoyed. My beef steak was well cooked and very tasty. There could have been more rosemary potatos but I guess that comes down to portion control. One of my fellow diners had the seafood mixed grill, which he said was good and tasty but was quite expensive for what it was.

Sadly the service was dreadful. The waiter's standard of English was poor. On placing the order I tried to ascertain whether our meals were complete or if they needed any side orders. He just did not understand the question so I ordered French beans and broccolli anyway. As we were enjoying our gin and tonic aperitifs he brought the botle of Chianti and offered a taste. I pointed out that I still had half a glass of gin and tonic left and I would try the wine when that was finished. Why do restaurants offer wine tasting when they can see you are still drinking the aperitif? Some drinks don't mix well and it spoils the enjoyment of both of them. It should be basic customer serviceto observe this and also, I assume, they want their wine to be appreciated. This delay in the wine tasting proved to be our undoing. Gin and tonics were completed. The starters arrived, were enjoyed and the plates taken away. The full bottle of wine just stood there and was ignored by every member of staff that passed our table. Eventually I brought it to the attention of one of the, assumed, management team. His response was “Well you could have asked” I pointed out that asking was what I was currently doing. He then asked if I wanted to taste the wine and I said yes. He poured the wine into the white wine glasses after I had said it was OK. One of our group insisted it served in a red wine glass and got some interesting non-verbal communication. At no time did anyone top up our glasses and for the rest of the evening we were left to fend for ourselves… More

27 May 2011

Overall:6
Food and Drink:8
Service:1
Atmosphere:2
Value for Money:4
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Harry's Bar (5 Abchurch Yard, London, EC4N 7BA)

I have lunched here a few times and have always been very pleased with the result. They offer both a full a la carte restaurant menu and also a shorter bar menu. We always make clear which we need when booking the table. The welcome is always warm and they have some very quiet alcoves if you want that business lunch that might not be overheard at the next table.

The wine list, as you may expect, is very impressive and reasonably priced bearing in mind the City location. It can get expensive, however, if you go for glasses of wine rather than a bottle.

I have developed a real penchant for their scrambled eggs and smoke salmon. The eggs taste wonderful and are clearly freshly prepared. My lunching partner will usually go for the very attractive prawn and avocado salad. Both meals accompanied by a bowl of chips make a perfect business lunch.

Although tucked away in Abchurch Yard it is well worth seeking out and giving them a visit. You will be pleasantly surprised and certainly not regret your decision.

8 May 2011

Overall:8
Drinks:8
Service:9
Atmosphere:7
Value for Money:7
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Quaglino's (16 Bury Street, London, SW1Y 6AJ)

We have recently been to Quaglino's on 2 separate occasions to enjoy their special menu. The evening comes complete with a glass of champagne and the lunch with either a glass of red or white wine. Incredible value for money.

On both occasions the food and service were very good. The portions were ampleenough to be enjoyable and not leave feeling full and uncomfortable. My starter of carpaccio beetroot with goats cheese and walnut was excellent. The beef I had was well cooked and extremely tender, accompanied by a very tasty and subtly flavoured horesradish mash. 2 of my party also opted fro the beef, I am not sure what a featherblade is, but with clean plates and appreciative comments I know it was a good choice. 1 of the party opted for the stone bass. I am told it was delicious with a hint of chilli. In fact, it was called the best fish dish that had been enjoyed for some time.

For desert I have enjoyed both the Eton mess and the Passionfruit mess. 1 of my guests today had the ginger and rhubarb and I am told it was delicious with the rhubarb not being over sweetened and retaining it's tart flavour. The pavlova looked to be a little tough to cut but I am reliable informed tasted terrific.

Whilst there amazing offers continuie it is a place to visit on a regular occasion and enjoy the experience.

January 2011

Overall:9
Food and Drink:8
Service:9
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:10
0 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Benares (12a Berkeley Square House, Berkeley Square, London, W1J 6BS)

Lunch at Benares was a very enjoyable experience. It began with the welcome on the ground floor. I have had better welcomes on previous visits but this went the through the processes, although the usual warmth was sadly lacking. We were shown to our table in the corner, which gave a very good view of the restaurant. The decor is very restful and the use of dark wood and light walls makes it feel very homely and relaxing. We chose to have the platter menu. My meat platter offered 3 different types of meat. An excellent soup served along with pilau rice and naan. It was very good and quite filling. My partner chose the fish platter and I am told that of the 3 different fish offerings the sea bass was quite wonderful. We both enjoyed a rose petal flavoured desert. It was very subtle in flavour, light and delicious. The bill with the addition of a very good mango lassi and mineral water was less than £40 each, including service. Overall a very good experience to be repeated before too long. They just need to fix the welcoming.

January 2011

Overall:9
Food and Drink:9
Service:9
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Restaurant Critic


Trinity (4 The Polygon, London, London, SW4 0JG)

Sunday lunch on a warm weekend proved to be a very enjoyable experience. The ambiance and service were both very good.

I began with the parfait of foie gras and chicken liver. It was very well served and full of flavour once one got used to the consistency of the parfait against a pate. My partner had the chilled pea and mint soup which resulted in some acknowledgment of the excellent flavour and how refreshing it was.

For mains I had the roast beef and yorkshire pudding. The beef was excellent. The Yorkshire pudding was very large and a bit over cooked but the flavour was good. From my research, over a number of years, I can report that there are better Yorkshire puddings in London but this was acceptable. The salmon was off the menu and my partner had the alternative, which I think was sea bass. There was a very small quantity on the plate and we were not advised on the need to sides. Some Jersey Royals would have complimented it very well.

Onto desert, we both went for the meringues in cold custard. It was very well presented and with the cherry compote and the caramel it held a number of very delightful flavours.

The set Sunday lunch is now £30 and there was no offer of an a la carte menu so one assumes that is all that is on offer. We enjoyed a very good bottle of wine to compliment the meal. The wine list is quite extensive and, in most cases, reasonably priced.

We look forward to returning and sampling the fuller menu.

June 2010

Overall:9
Food and Drink:8
Service:9
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Luc's Brasserie (17-22 Leadenhall Market, London, EC3V 1LR)

This restaurant has long been a favourite of City types for lunch. It now also opens for dinner and that is what took us to the restaurant. Sadly it was certainly not very full for a Thursday evening, it deserves to do better.

Both food and service were very good. 2 of us had the fillet steak, complete with excellent frites. It was as good, if not better, than some of competition who tend to specialise more in this type of meal. As I recall from the past, my friend who had the sole remarked that it was prepared and cooked perfectly. The fourth member of our party opted for a casserole with assorted meat and game that would most certainly have represented a vegetarian's nightmare.

We opted for a bottle of the house red wine which was very drinkable and complemented the dishes well, even the fish.

A return visit is on the cards before too long.

June 2010

Overall:9
Food and Drink:9
Service:9
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Clos Maggiore (33 King Street, London, WC2E 8JD)

As previously highlighted in a former review the lunch menu here is extremely good value £19.50 for 3 courses. Additionally there is an option to take 2 courses and enjoy a half bottle of wine for the same price. There are 3 options to choose from for each of the courses. The chiiled asparagus soup with a parmesan biscuit was very good on a warm day. My beef was very well cooked and presented and my fellow diner indicated that the pollock was also very good and it looked well presented and very meaty. We both enjoyed the tart and creme anglais for desert.

We were fortunate in being seated in the conservatory and it is a very beautiful location on a bright sunny day. Sadly the service was a bit suspect. The gaps between the courses were excessively long. Indeed, we were presented with a complimentary glass of wine to make up for the situation. It was a working lunch with lots to discuss so we coped with the gaps very well.

The sampling menus, both meat eating and vegetarian, look very good with or without the accompanying wines. It is certainly worth returning as friends inform me that our experience of the service was very much a lapse and does not reflect the usual dining experience.

June 2010

Overall:7
Food and Drink:8
Service:6
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:9
0 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Zilli Fish (36-40 Brewer Street, London, W1F 9TB)

Having heard many good things about Zilli Fish I looked forward to my lunch there with a former colleague. It was a Thursday and the restaurant was almost empty. Well under 50% occpancy and this failed to create any sort of positive atmosphere.

I began the meal with Calamari and sweet chilli sauce. It was OK for a cheaper chain reastaurant but certainly did not delight the palate. For my main course I opted for what the menu described as Merluzzo Tempura. Fish and chips to you and me. The fish, Icelandic Cod, was certainly meaty but was a little too moist inside and could have done with a little more cooking. My friend had the mixed fish salad and commented that it was sad to see, what was probably a very good piece of fish spoiled in terms of both texture and flavour.

We declined desert and the fairly simple meal accompanied by a bottle of house white wine came to £110. It was certainly not value for money.

The location is excellent but I think the occupancy level shoud have given us a warning of what was to come. In total, it was very disappointing when compared to some of the other restaurants that specialise in fish and seafood.

June 2010

Overall:6
Food and Drink:4
Service:5
Atmosphere:3
Value for Money:3
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Roast (Floral Hall, Stoney Street, London, SE1 1TL)

On a light and warm summer's evening, this is a superb location for an early dinner booking. The ambiance of the restaurant is superb and sitting near the large windows overlooking the activities outside is great for people watching.

2 of my friends had the £26 dinner menu, which offered extremely good value for money. In particular the comments and clear enjoyment of the belly of pork, complete with crackling, was great to hear. I also gather the crumble and custard was exteremly good. I opted for the a la carte menu and went for the roast chicken. The portion was enormous and when enjoyed with some of the excellent roast potato it was superb. The accompanying bacon and bread sauce enhanced the dish really well. The general comments from my firends, who were dining there for the first time, was that the portions of all the dishes was very generous and certainly met in full the large appetites they had brought with them. The wine list is very good and offers both affordable and high end prices. It was good to see some English wines included.

It is not always clear when making a booking here that there is a 2 hour table turn but we found that did not cause us any difficulty. Some of guests were delayed a little in their arrival at the restaurant but the staff ensured, through good service, that the meal was served comfortably within the timeframe. It did not feel rushes at all.

Since eating there a few friends have advised me that the breakfast at roast is also excellent so that will be added to the diary before too long.

June 2010

Overall:8
Food and Drink:8
Service:8
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
0 of 1 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Oscar at the Charlotte Street Hotel (Charlotte Street Hotel, 15-17 Charlotte Street, London, W1T 1RJ)

Lunch at Oscar in the Charlotte Street Hotel was a very enjoyable and memorable experience. The decor is interesting and different and certainly not stuffy as some hotel restaurants can become.

The food and service were both very good. It was a busy lunchtime service but that did nothng to distract from the quality of the food which arrived in a reasonable time. The Baked Alaska was particularly well prepared and fulfilled all of the expectations. My main course of veal was very well cooked and presented. The flavours supported the visual impression of the dish very well. My colleague and I both commented on what an enjoyable experience Oscar had given us and our intention to return.

The only downside is that the restrooms are a little way away from the restaurant and that involves a few stairs. I am not sure if they have anywhere available as an alternative for diners with mobility issues.

April 2010

Overall:9
Food and Drink:8
Service:9
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:8
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Quo Vadis (26-29 Dean Street, London, W1D 3LL)

Editor's pick

The new Sunday lunch offering at Quo Vadis was excellent. There was a very family orientated atmosphere in the restaurant and it felt very good and relaxed. A 3 course lunch for £35, which includes a half bottle of wine, water, coffee and service was incredibly good value. The service was ever present and attentive without being intrusive. Watching the maitre'd was a masterclass in good management and service. Throughout our visit he knew what was happening at each table and intervened when he thought it was necessary.

The smoked salmon starter was served with a circular accompaniment of hard boiled egg, chopped very finely and herbs. My roast beef was served excellently medium rare, although I was not asked if I had a preference. The ‘trimmings’ were very good, although a 3rd roast potato and possibly a little more gravy would have made it perfection. I am told by my partner that the sea bream was very good and cooked incredibly well. The desert was very good and well presented but did not totally reflect the decscription on the menu.

All considered it was an excellent experience that needs to be repeated sooner rather than later.

November 2009

Overall:9
Food and Drink:9
Service:10
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:10
2 of 2 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Smiths of Smithfield (67-77 Charterhouse Street, London, EC1M 6HJ)

There can be few more pleasurable ways to spend a leisurely summer Sunday lunch, than on the balcony of the top floor of Smiths of Smithfield.

It was a beautiful day and the ability to sit outside under the awnings provided a very relaxed and enjoyable location for lunch. The food was excellent. I am not sure what has been happening recently in the kitchens there but, on this occasion, the food was much better than we have enjoyed on previous visits. My eggs benedict to start with was very well presented and the egg poached to perfection. My friends had the smoked eel and the calamari as their starters and similar comments of satisfaction were expressed.

A very good bottle of Gigondas, sensibly priced, accompanied our meal.

For the main course I thoroughly enjoyed my roast beef and Yorkshire pudding, my friends had the roast lamb and the lobster. The meal and the accompanying vegetables were will cooked and seasoned, with no evidence of the ‘over seasoning’ that can sometimes happen at Smiths of Smithfield.

I declined the desert but I gather, from the appreciative comments, that the creme brulee and the tarte au citron were excellent.

To top off the occasion spendidly we were served by a waitress, who we learned is from Sydney. She was attentive without being intrusive and certainly added value to the selection of both the food and the wine. Smith's are to be complimented on securing her services and she is certainly very skilled and competent in providing a high standard of customer service. Regardless of the food, good service is often a reason for returning, or not returning, to a particular restaurant. On the evidence of our last experience we shall return.

June 2009

Overall:9
Food and Drink:9
Service:9
Atmosphere:9
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

The Chancery (9 Cursitor Street, London, EC4A 1LL)

Entering The Chancery on a quiet Tuesday evening gives one 2 immediate impressions. Firstly it strikes you as being very functional in design and layout. That is not necessarily a bad thing. Secondly, it is very quiet, or was the evening we were there. I imagine that because of it's location it will be more heavily reliant on a lunchtime trade than an evening one.

The fixed price menu was very good value. I thoroughly enjoyed a minestrone soap with tagliatelle, my friends told me that the scallops were very good and nicely brown on one side. For main course 2 of us opted for the steak and hand cut fries. The steak, for some reason, was sliced as you might find served in a stroganoff. It was very well cooked, medium rare, and therefore didn't need to be presented in this way. The hand cut fries were excellent and certainly were viewed enviously by my fellow diners.

Only 2 of the party opted for desert. The selection of ice cream listed on the menu seemed to cause some confusion when our waitress was asked what flavours there were to choose from. I undersatnd that what did arrive was very good.

It was a very enjoyable evening and ideal if you want a quiet dinner with a colleague or client. If you were looking for somewhere with a little more atmosphere you might find it a little too quiet. The value for money, bearing in mind, it's location at the edge of the City and in the legal environment of Chancery Lane, was very good. It is quite tucked away and may not always benefit from a passing crowd. I think you would need to know it is there and to seek it out. I don't think you will be disappointed.

May 2009

Overall:7
Food and Drink:7
Service:6
Atmosphere:6
Value for Money:9
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Joe Allen (13 Exeter Street, London, WC2E 7DT)

Editor's pick

Although it has been tucked away on Exeter Street more years than I care to remember it is not often that Joe Allen fails to hit the spot. They were probably one of earlier pioneers of ‘table turning’ but they usually do it with such finesse that one doesn't feel annoyed. They also go to great lengths on making the booking to be sure you understand how long you have the table for.

Sunday bruch/lunch is always fun and extremely good value. The regular changes to the menu avoid becoming over familiar with it as there is always something new to discover. The old faithfuls like the Caesar Salad, Eggs Benedict and the, never advertised, burgers are extremely good. the french fries are wonderful and one should enjoy them with the homemade tomato relish.

The pre and post theatre menu works really well if yuo are on a budget. For people who like to watch other people there is usually someone in there who you might recognise.

In a city like London a restaurant cannot survive in the way Joe Allen does, without having that certain something. Most times it is a very good meal, well served and accompanied by an interesting wine list.

April 2009

Overall:7
Food and Drink:7
Service:7
Atmosphere:8
Value for Money:8
4 of 4 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal
1 2
Advertisement