Offer Finder

  • Search Available Offers

Book with us & collect points to spend on fantastic rewards. It is that simple.
Learn more »?

Register here for your Square Meal Guides

 
 
(menu)

Daniel's Reviews

Daniel H.40s, Male, United Kingdom

Member since August 2011

Reviews written: 2 (1 voted helpful)

Restaurants rated: 2 (this year)

Posts written: 2

Andrew Edmunds (46 Lexington Street, London, W1F 0LP)

I have a system when I sit down in a restaurant. On being handed a menu I first look at the choices of main course. Based on that decision I then chose something complimentary to start and an appropriate drink. This system has served me well for the last 30 years. The only time it comes off the rails is on the very rare occasion that I can’t choose a main course.

This is what happened on my last visit to Andrew Edmunds. The choices on the daily menu on that particular day all sounded amazing. In a way I would have been happier if the staff had chosen at random and delivered their offering as a surprise.

In the end I opted for the scallops ceviche to start and the gnocchi for a main course with a beautiful and reasonable priced bottle of St Aubin. It was a delicious meal. I loved my starter; it was full of small scallops with mixed leaves and a refreshing sauce. Main course was just as good with a wonderful tomato and ricotta sauce. My only criticism of the entire night was that the base on my treacle tart was slightly (and I do mean slightly) too thick. I washed it down with the nicest bottle of Tokaji ever.

As for the service, well, it was as brilliant as the meal. I have been going to Andrew Edmunds since the early 90’s and it is consistently excellent. I can think of few London restaurants that can deliver this level of satisfaction.

23 August 2011

Overall:10
Food and Drink:9
Service:10
Atmosphere:10
Value for Money:10
2 of 2 people found this review helpful. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal

Hix (66-70 Brewer Street, London, London, W1F 9UP)

When I arrived at Mark’s bar in the basement of Hix’s my friends had already been waiting for half an hour. At the time I assumed that they were waiting for me before ordering. I didn’t look at the menu but just decided on a gin gimlet (gin & lime cordial over ice) and my friends ordered their cocktails from the menu. The room is beautiful with a lot of thought having clearly gone into the height of the bar and chairs. I thought the NY style ceiling was particularly attractive.

Everyone had tap water and glasses on their table which was a good thing as it was the hottest day of the year and after twenty minutes our drinks had still not arrived. We asked about that and were told that it was a ‘complicated’ order. After a further ten minutes (I know because our table upstairs in the restaurant was held for us) we opted to go up and order food. Our drinks followed a few minutes later. I think that if your menu is so complicated that three built cocktails and one shaken cocktail take 30 minutes then a redesign may be in order. I could have ordered, gone to the pub next door, had a pint and returned in the time it took to get a drink at Mark’s. And I would have done that if I had known the wait we had to endure.

The menu in the restaurant is clearly designed by someone who wants the world to know how clever he is. I’ve worked in catering for ten years and still had a few questions. If your first thought on reading the menu is ‘I feel stupid’ perhaps that’s not the most welcoming message.

Overly complicated descriptions aside I opted to start the meal with a plate of heritage tomatoes with crab and chives. It arrived looking beautiful on the plate and tasting wonderful. As for the main course I decided on simple grilled mackerel with broad beans and tomato relish. It’s nice to see that the overcomplicated quality of the menu was not carried through to the cooking. Perhaps what they really need is just a good proofreader.

My friend ordered a medium steak with chips and a… More

4 August 2011

Overall:4
Food and Drink:8
Service:7
Atmosphere:6
Value for Money:4
This review hasn't been rated yet. Was it helpful to you?
Request review removal
Advertisement