Sylvester's restaurant is closed permanently. Here are some other restaurants near Sylvester's you might like to try.

Sylvester's

International, Scottish·
££££
·
·

SquareMeal Review of Sylvester's

Since taking over what was the much-loved Pink Olive, Kieran and Nicola Sylvester's eponymous restaurant has picked up on the offbeat quality and value that made its predecessor such a hit with students and locals alike. Located just a stroll from Bristo Square and the heart of Edinburgh’s Festival activity, this small but perfectly formed eatery has an impressive festival menu, but it's the year-round offering which is the most impressive – particularly as prices are pitched for comfort. Pay your money for smoked mackerel and lemon pâté, haggis bonbons or toasted goats’ cheese and Kalamata olive bruschetta, ahead of oriental-style confit duck, pollock and chips or wild mushroom risotto. Light lunches also bring sharing platters, deli sandwiches, superfood salads and suchlike, while desserts maintain the please-all theme with banoffi cheesecake or chocolate and orange brownie.

Good to know

Average Price
££££ - Under £30
Cuisines
International, Scottish

Location

55-57 West Nicolson Street, Edinburgh, EH8 9DB

0131 662 4493 0131 662 4493

Website

Opening Times

Tues-Sat 11.30am-2pm 5pm-10pm

Reviews

Share your thoughts with other diners

Write a review


1 Review 
Food/Drink
Service
Atmosphere
Value

Anon

28 August 2020  
Food & Drink 0.5
Service 4
Atmosphere 0.5
Value 0.5
Outrageous!

I recently dined at Sylvester's and I have to say I was far from impressed. The chef should be sacked and charged with attempted murder. I ordered a steak medium rare and I could have sworn I saw it jump off of my plate it was that raw. My 79 year old wife suffered from terrible food poisoning after eating the fish cake. We had even feared it was corona virus, it was that severe. The waiter was very helpful, however. He catered very well to our needs and was the standout in a mediocre restaurant. I will certainly not be returning to Sylvester's any time soon, and indefinitely if that chef remains in post. 

Sorry, you cannot spend SquareMeal vouchers here yet.

Other restaurants we like near Sylvester's

Junk
Newington

Junk

La Garrigue
Edinburgh Waverley

La Garrigue

Tattu Edinburgh
Edinburgh

Tattu Edinburgh

Check availability